Tartarean Desire logo On the web since 2000 image
REVIEW: Edge Of Sanity - Crimson II Black Mark Production, 2003
8/10
Edge Of Sanity - Crimson II - cover art When I heard that Dan Swanö was going to forge on and create Crimson II under the Edge Of Sanity name by himself, with a few assisting musicians to provide texture, I almost flipped out. Not out of anger that he thinks himself worthy to imitate an entire, legendary band (I had faith he could pull it off), but out of fear that he might screw up Crimson's musical legacy by churning out a sub-par second chapter to an unquestionable masterpiece. I think I still would have felt trepidation had the rest of the band still been backing him. Anyways, my fears were completely unfounded, as ever reliable Dan has belted out a greatly worthy successor/sequel to Crimson in Crimson II. But is it as incredible as Crimson I? Is it a masterpiece? Simply put, it is not. Crimson I had the freshest (not in a homey white-trash sense mind you, dawg) riffs imaginable and a slightly fuzzy production that suited the atmosphere perfectly. Crimson II is also a bit fuzzed, but in a somewhat negative way. Dan's growl sounds curiously hollow throughout, the guitars lack necessary distinction to an extent and the melodies simply aren't as melodic or as unique as the leads in the first album. In a way, it sounds just like how I expected it to sound, and this may be a black-mark (heh) against the album.

Crimson I was a startling revelation, Crimson II suffers from sequel syndrome in that it does what it does excellently, but that spark from the original is missing. Now, despite my beef with the production and the fact that Crimson II isn't as original or startling as it could have been, there are many praise-worthy things to be heard here. The lyrics are brilliantly written, almost surprisingly so, providing an exhilirating new chapter in the Crimson story. The use of keyboards, ala Dan's Moontower, adds needed texture and lushness to some sections, generating a likeable amalgamation of deathier EoS moments and Dan's proggy sensibilities. The 45 minutes are broken into 7 sections (something I disapprove of, but it's not a big deal), and taken as one work, it flows very well, being tightly structured and comprised of many varied sections. There are a few standout riffs and some eargasmic bits here and there. Dan's clean vocals don't appear as much as I would have liked them too, but that really just makes these sections especially tasty. Overall, the good points far out-weigh the bad, but the bad keep this from being what it could have been. However, this should only solidify Dan Swanö's reputation as one of the most incredible musicians in music, period, considering he plays almost all of the instruments and can single-handedly create a massively epic album in spite of the absence of 80% of Edge of Sanity. Worthy, but disappointing in a way. Check it out anyways, as it still deserves to be listened to and is generally pretty excellent.

written by Tim Blake

Find out more about the band

» Edge Of Sanity band details
Tracklist
1. Crimson II: The Forbidden
2. Crimson II: Incantation
3. Crimson II: Passage Of Time
4. Crimson II: The Silent Threat
5. Crimson II: Achilles Heel
6. Crimson II: Covenant Of Souls
7. Crimson II: Face To Face
8. Crimson II: Disintegration
9. Crimson II: Aftermath

Playing time: 45.00

Buy other Edge Of Sanity albums
Search this site

Newsletter

E-mail address:

Subscribe
Unsubscribe