Tartarean Desire logo On the web since 2000 image
Buy this album
REVIEW: Oblivion Myth - Between Light and Shadow , 2008
7.5/10
Oblivion Myth - Between Light and Shadow - cover art It’s almost simple to accuse Nashville’s Oblivion Myth as a band mired in either self-absorption or stasis, because not only is Between Light and Shadow a reheated version of an earlier self-titled album with a different vocalist – itself recorded twice with two disparate lineups – but it’s since been re-re-re-released with the band’s new singer Sterling Whitmill. The practice of slapping a new coat of paint on an old car is becoming a most odious trend in metal these days and it’s high time that someone called out the likes of Iced Earth, Arch Enemy and a dozen other offenders: you made those albums already, move on, live with it. Anyhow, dealing with the album under consideration, is this third time a charm? For the most part, yes. As the band’s name rightfully suggests, this is somewhere between power and prog metal, adept personnel hawking their wares with a healthy dose of bash-it-out intensity that pushes this occasionally and healthily into the thrash (or ‘80s power metal) realm. I’m feeling early Symphony X and Evergrey, or Kamelot when they were still recording analog, maybe a touch of Steel Prophet with Destiny's End choral phrasing by erstwhile Fatal Opera singer Andy Freeman, who also produces this thing with workmanlike proficiency. There isn’t a song here that wouldn’t benefit from some pruning and trimming, but overall it makes for a fine debut...and sophomore...and follow-up...and fourth record. Thankfully, the band seems to have gotten past some of this navel-gazing and recorded a proper second album, seemingly due any day now.

written by Matthew Kirshner

Tracklist
1. Gathering of Souls
2. Dimensions
3. Believer Deceiver
4. Knightserrant
5. Evil of All Corners
6. Twilight Dementia
7. Mirroracle
8. Mystique

Playing time: 48:07

Buy other Oblivion Myth albums
Search this site

Newsletter

E-mail address:

Subscribe
Unsubscribe