Tartarean Desire logo On the web since 2000 image
Buy this album
REVIEW: Pain Of Salvation - Entropia Inside Out Music, 1999
6.5/10
Pain Of Salvation - Entropia - cover art Pain Of Salvation is widely considered to be one of the great innovators of that obscure genre 'progressive metal'. Often mistaken for music of extreme technical proficiency and over-emotional vocalists who wail insanely, I've never found the popular idea of 'progressive metal' as quite how I would class it. I'd call Maudlin of the Well or Opeth 'progressive metal' for example, not Dream Theater. For one of the 'great innovators' of progressive metal, if Pain Of Salvation's Entropia is any indication of their overall sound and general aesthetic then I don't really want to hear any more. The album starts VERY promisingly with '!(Foreword)', which has a great opening riff and some excellent guitar melodies and playing. Also, vocalist Gildenlöw performs pretty excellently on it, hitting some good notes. The only low point is the incessant repeating of 'I'm not afraid, I'm not afraid of you' towards the end, it's annoying. From here on in it's a downhill slide but with one exception, the truly brilliant 'People Passing By'. The jazzy-bass playing, smooth drumming and vocals, as well as the lovely midsection, make it the one perfect song on the album. Now here's where I sling the mud.

The rest of the album is disappointing to me because of the vocalist I'm afraid. The majority of his lyrics are very trite, and he just tries too damn hard, dammit. Take 'Winning A War' for example. It starts out sounding like it will blow your mind and then Gildenlöw gets carried away and starts crying for his mommy and daddy. 'Oblivion Ocean' suffers a similar fate, being nice for a while and quickly wearing thin with Gildenlöw's over-wrought, theatrical, emotion-mongering and cheesy lyrics. Song after song rolls by with over-the-top vocals wrecking some promising music. Now cheesy vocals and lyrics are O.K with me, but the reason why they really mess the album up is that the production is so dry. With the drums, guitar and bass sounding so on-the-surface and the overall production devoid of reverb or echo, Gildenlöw's bone-dry vocals are pushed to the forefront of EVERYTHING, their theatrical nature overpowering the music and wrecking the album for me. He IS a great vocalist, he just tries too hard here. They aren't wankers of instruments so much, no insane shredding here, but I sure hope Gildenlöw has curbed his vocal-indulgence on later albums. I've heard a few good songs from 'Remedy Lane' so I haven't given up on Pain Of Salvation yet, but I'm guessing that if you are interested in this band you should not make the same mistake I did and start with this album. It's a blur of similar songs and frustrating vocals.

written by Tim Blake

Find out more about the band » Pain Of Salvation band details
Tracklist
1. ! (Foreword)
2. Welcome To Entropia
3. Winning A War
4. People Passing By
5. Oblivion Ocean
6. Stress
7. Revival
8. Void Of Her
9. To The End
10. Circles
11. Nightmist
12. Plains Of Dawn
13. Leaving Entropia (Epilogue)

Playing time: 60.00

Buy other Pain Of Salvation albums
Search this site

Newsletter

E-mail address:

Subscribe
Unsubscribe